# Octopuses: Evolution’s Alternative Experiment

URL: https://interesting.weblocally.com/en/post/octopuses-evolution-s-alternative-experiment
Date: 2026-10-03
Updated: 2026-10-11
Sections: Body
Source: PubMed Central (PMC), https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10755184/
Russian version: https://interesting.weblocally.com/post/octopuses-evolution-s-alternative-experiment

> How intelligence and anatomy work in creatures with a distributed brain, three hearts, and display-like skin.

An octopus is fascinating not merely because it is a “smart mollusk.” It is an animal in which evolution, completely independent of vertebrates, built complex intelligence on an entirely different architecture: a soft, boneless body, a nervous system largely distributed across eight arms, suckers that can simultaneously touch and “taste” surfaces, skin that shifts color and texture, blue blood, and three hearts. That is why it is illuminating to view the octopus as an alternative evolutionary experiment in **“how else a complex animal can be built”** ([PubMed Central (PMC)](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10755184/)).

## 1. First things first: an octopus is actually a mollusk

Its close relatives are not dolphins, fish, or crabs, but **squid, cuttlefish, and nautiluses**—and, more distantly, snails and bivalves.

In broad strokes, the evolutionary lineage looks like this:

**mollusks → cephalopods → coleoids → octopus lineage → modern Octopoda**

This is where it gets interesting. Early cephalopods had protective shells. Over evolutionary time, many of their descendants abandoned this heavy external armor. Instead of a biological “tank,” a completely different toolkit emerged:

**speed + intelligence + camouflage + flexibility + sophisticated sensory organs.**

Smithsonian describes precisely this transition: early cephalopods relied on a shell, whereas many modern forms staked their survival on intelligence, flexible limbs, and the ability to hide. ([Smithsonian Ocean](https://ocean.si.edu/ocean-life/invertebrates/octopuses-squids-and-relatives))

This is a key insight into the octopus:

> it lacks armor and has virtually no rigid skeleton, turning its entire body into an all-purpose tool instead.

## 2. Their lineage is far older than the dinosaurs

Cephalopod history stretches back hundreds of millions of years. However, soft-bodied animals rarely fossilize well, which leaves the early record of octopuses shrouded in obscurity.

In 2022, researchers described the fossil **Syllipsimopodi bideni**, dated to roughly **330–324 million years ago**, interpreting it as the earliest known representative of the lineage leading to octopuses and the vampire squid. Intriguingly, this creature still possessed **10 limbs** rather than eight. ([Nature](https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-28333-5))

This also provides a textbook illustration of science in progress: in 2023, other paleontologists challenged that interpretation, arguing the fossil might belong to a different group of early cephalopods. The original authors defended their hypothesis in response. As a result, the exact origin of Octopoda still has unresolved gaps. ([Nature](https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-42842-x))

What emerges is an elegant evolutionary narrative:

**shell → reduction of internal skeleton → soft body → eight highly dexterous arms → enormous reliance on the nervous system and behavior.**

And all of this unfolded independently of the path taken by mammals and birds.

## 3. The most unusual aspect: their intelligence is nothing like ours

This is where the octopus truly starts to feel “alien.”

In vertebrates, the control hierarchy generally runs like this:

**brain → spinal cord → limbs.**

In an octopus, control is far more decentralized. Much of the complex neural processing occurs not just in the central brain, but directly within the nervous system of the arms. A massive nerve cord runs down each arm, local neural centers operate near the suckers, and the arm itself can process an immense volume of sensory information autonomously. ([PubMed Central (PMC)](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10755184/))

In other words, the brain does not need to micromanage commands like:

> “sucker #137, contract by 17%, and sucker next to it, rotate right.”

The central nervous system can issue a high-level goal:

**“explore that crevice”**

and the arm’s peripheral nervous system sorts out a substantial portion of the details on its own.

Because of this, the popular claim that **“an octopus has nine brains”** is catchy, but scientifically inaccurate.

It is more accurately described as:

**one central brain + an exceptionally developed distributed nervous system across eight arms.**

### 🧠 Stranger still: most of the nervous system is outside the central brain

In _Octopus vulgaris_, standard estimates identify roughly:

**~40 million neurons** in the central brain, **~130 million** in the optic lobes, **~350 million** in the nerve structures of the arms.

That means the majority of its neurons reside **in the arms**, not in the central brain. ([PubMed Central (PMC)](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10755184/))

So it is more accurate not to think of an octopus as:

**🧠 brain → commands 8 arms**

but rather:

**🧠 central brain** ↕ **🦾 local nervous system of each arm** ↕ **⭕ hundreds of suckers with their own sensory clusters**

A 2024 study underscored the sheer complexity of this architecture: hundreds of repeating neural ganglia run along each arm, supplemented by additional neural centers at the base of each sucker. ([PubMed](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39326412/))

### 🖐️ A severed arm can still perform complex movements

This sounds like science fiction, but neurophysiological experiments have confirmed it.

Even an amputated arm can, for a time:

**move, respond to tactile stimuli, coordinate individual suckers, and exhibit grasping-like motions.** ([PubMed Central (PMC)](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10755184/))

This does not mean the arm is an independent, sentient entity.

Rather, it illustrates how many **pre-programmed motor routines reside directly inside the arm itself**.

From an engineering standpoint, this is an ingenious solution.

Instead of:

> “the central processor calculates the position of every single sucker,”

the setup becomes:

> “the main brain sets the objective; local controllers handle the execution details.”

It bears an uncanny resemblance to a distributed computing system.

## 4. Their arms can also “taste”

This is easily one of their most remarkable adaptations.

An octopus’s suckers contain specialized **chemotactile receptors**.

For humans, the division of labor is familiar:

**hand = touch**

**tongue = taste**

**nose = smell**

For an octopus:

**sucker = touch + chemical analysis of the surface.**

Studies have shown that these receptors detect poorly soluble molecules upon direct contact. As an octopus slips an arm into a crevice, it registers the texture of the rock and the chemical signature of potential prey simultaneously. ([PubMed Central (PMC)](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7605239/))

In 2025, research uncovered an even more surprising mechanism: these receptors can respond to chemical compounds produced by the **surface microbiome**.

Touching a stone can reveal vastly more information to an octopus than touching it with a human finger ever could. ([PubMed Central (PMC)](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12354320/))

### 🐙 Why octopuses do not stick to themselves

Consider the logistical dilemma: eight arms carrying **hundreds of suckers**, each primed to latch onto any suitable surface almost automatically.

Without a built-in fail-safe, any movement could spiral into chaos:

**arm #1 → sticks to #4 → #4 grabs #7 → #7 grabs the head → 🤦**

Yet this virtually never happens.

Researchers discovered that **octopus skin contains a chemical signal** detected by the suckers that **inhibits the grasping reflex**. Even an amputated arm that moves and grasps objects will generally avoid sticking to octopus skin. ([PubMed](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24835454/))

The feedback loop works roughly like this:

**sucker touches rock** → sensory signal → **GRAB**

**sucker touches octopus skin** → chemical signal “this is octopus” → automatic grab is inhibited.

Crucially, this happens **locally**, without needing clearance from the central brain every time.

Even more intriguing is that a living octopus can **override this inhibition** when necessary to grasp its own arm or body. This indicates at least two layers of control:

**local tier:** “do not automatically grab yourself” **central tier:** “override: I actually need to hold this right now.” ([ScienceDirect](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S096098221400462X))

It is an extraordinary example of bodily tissues handling computational work directly.

## 5. Skin that functions like a biological display

An octopus can transform its appearance in a matter of seconds.

Its skin contains specialized structures, including **chromatophores**—elastic pigment sacs controlled by tiny muscles that expand and contract. Their movement creates spots, bands, and shifting color patterns. ([Monterey Bay Aquarium](https://www.montereybayaquarium.org/animals-the-ocean/animals-a-to-z/cephalopods))

Color, however, is only half the equation.

Octopuses can also alter the **three-dimensional texture of their skin**.

A smooth-bodied octopus:

**◯**

can, moments later, resemble:

**🪨**

sprouting bumps, ridges, and spikes that mimic a rock, a coral head, or sea algae. Smithsonian documents individuals shifting seamlessly between perfectly smooth and heavily textured skin. ([Smithsonian Ocean](https://ocean.si.edu/ocean-life/invertebrates/pair-octopuses))

Its camouflage is therefore multilayered, combining:

**color + pattern + brightness + body posture + skin texture + movement style.**

This goes well beyond standard camouflage; it is closer to **rendering the surrounding environment across the surface of its own body**.

---

### 🎨 The great paradox: flawless color matching despite apparent color blindness

Octopus retinas typically contain only **a single type of visual pigment**, which means they are traditionally considered color-blind.

Yet they routinely pull off feats like this:

**🪨 stone → match the stone🌿 seaweed → match the seaweed🪸 coral → mirror the intricate pattern**

And their skin shifts far more than mere pigment.

The system relies on:

**chromatophores** → pigment manipulation, **iridophores** → structural light reflection, **leucophores** → broad-spectrum light scattering, **papillae** → physical alteration of skin texture.

Some of these visual transitions occur in less than a second. ([DOI](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2023.08.095))

Science still lacks a complete, definitive explanation for how an animal with monochromatic vision matches colors in its environment with such fidelity. ([PubMed](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36278671/))

---

## 6. Octopus varieties differ far more than most people realize

The modern order **Octopoda** is divided primarily into two major lineages: **Incirrata**, which includes most familiar bottom-dwelling octopuses, and **Cirrata**, deep-sea forms characterized by fins and small sensory projections (cirri) along their suckers. ([World Register of Marine Species](https://www.marinespecies.org/aphia.php?id=11718&p=taxdetails))

Looking at specific species reveals just how diverse they are.

### 🐙 Common octopus, _Octopus vulgaris_

The archetypal octopus of the Mediterranean and Atlantic. Typically associated with the seabed, rocky reefs, crevices, and dens, it is frequently found at depths down to roughly 100 m. It is widespread throughout the Mediterranean. ([FAO AGRIS](https://agris.fao.org/search/en/providers/122436/records/67599dfbc7a957febdfe8928))

Around places like Cyprus, this is not a rare exotic creature; it is the exact species one can encounter along the Mediterranean coast.

### 🦑 Giant Pacific octopus, _Enteroctopus dofleini_

Native to the North Pacific.

The titan of the octopus world. Smithsonian records an exceptional historical specimen weighing around **272 kg with an arm span of roughly 9 m**, though typical individuals are substantially smaller. The species excels at problem-solving and displays sophisticated exploratory behavior. ([Monterey Bay Aquarium](https://www.montereybayaquarium.org/visit/exhibits/giant-pacific-octopus))

### 💙 Blue-ringed octopuses, _Hapalochlaena_

Small octopuses native to the Indo-Pacific.

Their vivid, iridescent blue rings serve as an aposematic warning. Despite their diminutive size, they rank among the most venomous marine animals on Earth.

### 🎭 Mimic octopus, _Thaumoctopus mimicus_

Found across Southeast Asia.

This species does not just change color; it manipulates its posture and locomotion to impersonate other marine animals, such as lionfish, flatfish, or sea snakes.

In essence:

**standard camouflage:** “I am not here.”

**mimicry:** “I am here, but I am definitely not an octopus.”

### 🥥 Coconut octopus, _Amphioctopus marginatus_

Inhabits the tropical Western Pacific.

Famous for behavior widely interpreted as tool use: gathering, carrying, and assembling discarded coconut half-shells or bivalve shells into portable shelters.

This demonstrates a crucial benchmark of advanced cognition:

**transporting an object now because it will serve a purpose later.**

That goes well beyond a simple immediate reflex.

### 🦋 Blanket octopus, _Tremoctopus_

Pelagic ocean dwellers.

Females can unfurl immense, billowing membranes between their arms, creating a magnificent defensive “cape.” Smithsonian also notes that they can wield torn-off tentacles of the Portuguese man-o’-war as defensive weapons. ([Smithsonian Ocean](https://ocean.si.edu/ocean-life/invertebrates/so-you-think-youre-smarter-cephalopod))

### 👻 Dumbo octopus

A completely different take on the octopus blueprint.

These deep-sea cirrates feature a pair of ear-like fins above their eyes and propel themselves primarily by flapping them, rather than relying on the jet propulsion typical of many other cephalopods.

NOAA has observed members of this group at depths approaching **4 km**. ([NOAA Ocean Exploration](https://oceanexplorer.noaa.gov/multimedia/video-playlist-arctic-dumbo/))

In appearance, it looks almost like a cross between an octopus and a tiny floating umbrella.

## 7. We are still discovering brand-new species

One striking example unfolded quite recently in scientific terms.

In 2016, a NOAA submersible encountered a small, nearly translucent, ghostly octopus off Hawaii at a depth of **4,290 meters**.

The internet quickly dubbed it:

**Casper octopus 👻**

Remarkably, as of February **2026**, it still lacks an official scientific name. While researchers have documented similar individuals on video multiple times, they have not yet collected a physical specimen suitable for formal taxonomic description. ([NOAA Ocean Exploration](https://oceanexplorer.noaa.gov/news/10-years-of-the-casper-octopus/))

Even in 2026, the situation stands:

> we know this extraordinary animal exists, we have captured it on high-definition video, but we still cannot place it definitively on the tree of life.

The deep ocean still holds undiscovered large animals.

## 8. Unusual internal anatomy: three hearts and blue blood

An octopus genuinely possesses **three hearts**.

Two branchial hearts pump blood through the gills to pick up oxygen.

One systemic heart circulates oxygenated blood through the rest of the body. ([Smithsonian Ocean](https://ocean.si.edu/ocean-life/invertebrates/octopuses-squids-and-relatives))

Its blood is also literally blue.

While humans rely on iron-based **hemoglobin** to transport oxygen,

cephalopods use copper-based **hemocyanin**.

Consequently:

**Fe → red**

**Cu → blue**

The biochemical properties of hemocyanin are well adapted to cephalopod marine physiology, including cold waters and fluctuating oxygen levels. ([Smithsonian Ocean](https://ocean.si.edu/ocean-life/invertebrates/octopuses-squids-and-relatives))

## 9. An almost entirely soft body

No spinal column.

No arm bones.

No rigid joints.

As a result, an octopus’s arm has an almost infinite number of degrees of freedom.

In robotics, that level of flexibility would be a control nightmare.

A human arm has a relatively small, fixed number of articulating joints.

In a soft octopus arm, practically every segment can:

**bend + twist + elongate + contract.**

This is precisely why octopuses are of intense interest to researchers in **soft robotics** today. Their anatomy demonstrates how complex movement can be orchestrated without rigid joints. Roboticists frequently invoke the concept of “embodied intelligence,” where part of the computational burden is resolved by the physical dynamics of the body itself rather than by a centralized controller. ([PubMed](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23098601/))

## 10. Genuine, formidable intelligence

Octopuses can learn, memorize spatial routes, explore unfamiliar objects, and solve puzzles. In captivity, giant Pacific octopuses navigate mazes and distinguish between individual human caretakers. ([Monterey Bay Aquarium](https://www.montereybayaquarium.org/visit/exhibits/giant-pacific-octopus))

Yet there is an important caveat.

One should not assume:

**“an octopus is smart almost like a human.”**

The reality is more profound:

**its intelligence is fundamentally unlike human intelligence.**

Our familiar intellectual peers—apes, dolphins, dogs, corvids—share a vertebrate body plan and a centralized nervous system built on familiar principles.

An octopus arrived at sophisticated cognition equipped with:

**a soft body + eight semi-autonomous arms + suckers + distributed information processing.**

It is a premier example of **convergent, independent evolution of complex intelligence**.

And that is why neurobiologists find them so compelling. ([PubMed](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30083937/))

## 11. The deepest puzzle: where does the “octopus” end and its arm begin?

Here, biology meets the philosophy of mind.

An arm can independently:

probe its surroundings,

process tactile and chemical signals,

coordinate dozens of suckers,

and execute intricate physical tasks.

Yet it remains integrated into a single organism, constantly communicating with the central brain.

This leads some cognitive scientists to pose a radical question:

> how unified is the internal experience of a creature with such a profoundly distributed nervous system?

Science does not yet have a settled answer. Research into octopus consciousness highlights this unique organizational structure without claiming that each arm represents an independent personality. ([PubMed](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35401127/))

### 😴 One more thing: their skin puts on a display while they sleep

Researchers have identified at least two distinct sleep states in octopuses.

During **quiet sleep**, the animal remains largely motionless, with pale, relaxed skin.

Periodically, it transitions into brief bouts of **active sleep**:

its eyes twitch, its mantle contracts, its skin texture shifts, and rapid waves of color and intricate patterns flicker across its body.

Neural recordings during these active sleep phases show bursts of activity that closely resemble patterns seen during wakefulness. ([PubMed Central (PMC)](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8101055/))

This naturally prompts an alluring question:

**could octopuses be dreaming?**

Here, scientific rigor must prevail over poetic speculation. The data confirms a physiological state **comparable in several respects to active or REM-like sleep**, but whether an octopus experiences subjective dreams in the way humans do remains impossible to prove.

---

## 12. An evolutionary twist: their lives are surprisingly short

This is one of the starkest evolutionary paradoxes in biology.

Nature assembled an organism with:

**a complex brain, learning, memory, dynamic camouflage, sophisticated camera eyes, and astonishing arms,**

yet many species live for only a few years—sometimes just one or two.

Most octopuses reproduce only once (semelparity). After laying her clutch, a female often guards and aerates the eggs continuously, refusing food. Shortly after the eggs hatch, her life ends.

In the giant Pacific octopus, Smithsonian details this prolonged maternal vigil: the mother cleans the eggs, gently bathes them in oxygenated water, and stays by their side until they hatch.

The resulting life-history strategy is stark:

**grow rapidly → become an apex invertebrate predator → reproduce once → die.**

It is the antithesis of the human strategy of “live long, learn over decades, and pass accumulated knowledge down to the next generation.”

## Why octopuses remain peerless

Compressing the entire picture into a single framework yields:

**🧬 ancestry:** an ancient mollusk lineage ↓ **🐚 loss of heavy armor:** reduction of the shell ↓ **🫥 new defense:** camouflage and dynamic shape-shifting ↓ **🧠 new architecture:** a decentralized, distributed nervous system ↓ **🖐️ novel sensory apparatus:** eight hyper-flexible arms, hundreds of suckers, tasting by touch ↓ **🎭 behavior:** learning, curiosity, mimicry, tool transport ↓ **🌊 outcome:** one of the most unconventional blueprints for a complex animal on Earth.

Calling an octopus merely **“the smartest invertebrate”** fails to do it justice.

It is far more rewarding to appreciate them as **a second, independently evolved model of complex intelligence**—living proof that brains, bodies, senses, and minds can be constructed on principles radically different from anything found in vertebrates. ([PubMed](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30083937/))

---

Interesting: https://interesting.weblocally.com/en/
